Step back into a sweeter, simpler time with Cheryl’s Old Fashioned Caramels—the timeless treat that celebrates the original caramel experience. Smooth, creamy, and rich with buttery flavor, these caramels are as close to the classics as it gets. No frills, no gimmicks—just pure, satisfying caramel made the way it should be.

Each caramel is handmade in small batches, carefully cooked to golden perfection, and lovingly wrapped by hand. This isn’t just candy—it’s a tribute to traditional confectionery, crafted with pride and care using ingredients you can pronounce.

Why You'll Love It:

• Traditional recipe with a rich, creamy finish

• No preservatives, no shortcuts—just honest caramel

• Made with real butter, pure vanilla, and heavy cream

• A nostalgic taste that brings back memories

• Gluten free & made with clean, non-GMO ingredients

Ingredients:

Granulated sugar, heavy cream (heavy cream, skim milk), Karo Light corn syrup (corn syrup, vanilla, salt – 0g high fructose corn syrup), unsalted butter (pasteurized cream, natural flavors), salt, and pure vanilla extract (water, alcohol, vanilla bean extract).
Contains: Milk.

Perfect For:

• Caramel purists and traditionalists

• Sharing with grandparents, teachers, or neighbors

• Classic candy dishes and gift baskets

• Savoring with coffee or tea for a simple pleasure moment

🎁 Want to sample them all? Try our Classic Sampler Box to experience Cheryl’s full range of signature flavors.

👉 Order now and rediscover what real caramel is supposed to taste like—smooth, buttery, and timeless.